Home page
 

Rated Cigars

Best Cigar Prices rated category features cigars that were reviewed and given top ratings (91+) by prestigious cigar publications such as Cigar Aficionado, Cigar Insider, Cigar Magazine and Smoke Magazine.

More

Our rated cigars are known for their exceptional quality and value and are among some of the best stogies on the market. We’re proud to offer premium cigars to our customers at a great price. These are some of the world’s finest cigars and they’re located all in one convenient place!

From Padron Anniversario Serie 1926 80th Anniversario Maduro, rated a 96 by Cigar Aficionado, to the Cohiba Black Supremo, rated a 9.5 by Smoke Magazine, we have all of the high rated cigars you’re looking for.

Can’t find what you’re looking for? Give us a call! Our customer service team is here to help you and will find a way to get you exactly what you’re looking for. You can reach Customer Service at 1-888-41-CIGAR, Monday through Friday from 9AM to 8PM and Saturday from 9AM to 5PM.

Less

Narrow Results

BRANDS



Availability
  •  In Stock Only
  •  Show All
Free Shipping
  •  Show Only Free Shipping
  •  Show All
Showing results 1 - 20 of 904 products
List ViewGrid View
Please wait while the page reloads
94
Cigar Aficionado has given this item a rating of
94

Camacho Corojo Churchill Natural

Box of 25

Size

7 x 48

More Info

Origin

Honduras

Wrapper

Corojo

Shape

Regular
Also available in: 5 Cigars
Box of 25
7 x 48
$159.95
$177.50 - 10% off
FAQ icon
92
Cigar Aficionado has given this item a rating of
92

Rocky Patel Vintage 1990 Robusto

Box of 20

Size

5 1/2 x 50

More Info

Origin

Honduras

Wrapper

Maduro

Shape

Regular
Also available in: 5 Cigars, 1 Cigar
Box of 20
5 1/2 x 50
$152.95
$179.00 - 15% off
FAQ icon
92
Cigar Aficionado has given this item a rating of
92

Rocky Patel Vintage 1990 Robusto

5 Cigars

Size

5 1/2 x 50

More Info

Origin

Honduras

Wrapper

Maduro

Shape

Regular
Also available in: Box of 20, 1 Cigar
5 Cigars
5 1/2 x 50
$47.95
$53.70 - 11% off
FAQ icon
93
Cigar Aficionado has given this item a rating of
93

Aging Room Quattro F55 Concerto

Box of 20

Size

7 x 50

More Info

Origin

Dominican Republic

Wrapper

Rosado

Shape

Regular
Also available in: 5 Cigars
Box of 20
7 x 50
$158.95
$177.00 - 10% off
FAQ icon
92
Cigar Aficionado has given this item a rating of
92

Aging Room Quattro F55 Maestro

Box of 20

Size

6 x 52

More Info

Origin

Dominican Republic

Wrapper

Sumatra

Shape

Regular
Box of 20
6 x 52
$155.95
$173.80 - 10% off
FAQ icon
94
Cigar Insider has given this item a rating of
94

Aging Room Small Batch M356 Forte

Box of 20

Size

5 7/8 x 56

More Info

Origin

Dominican Republic

Wrapper

Habano

Shape

Perfecto
Box of 20
5 7/8 x 56
$137.95
$164.80 - 16% off
FAQ icon
94
Cigar Insider has given this item a rating of
94

Aging Room Small Batch M356 Motivo

Box of 20

Size

6 x 46

More Info

Origin

Dominican Republic

Wrapper

Habano

Shape

Regular
Box of 20
6 x 46
$132.95
$148.00 - 10% off
FAQ icon
94
Cigar Insider has given this item a rating of
94

Aging Room Small Batch M356 Presto by Habana Cuba

Box of 20

Size

4 1/2 x 48

More Info

Origin

Dominican Republic

Wrapper

Habano

Shape

Regular
Also available in: 1 Cigar
Box of 20
4 1/2 x 48
$129.95
$145.00 - 10% off
FAQ icon
91
Cigar Insider has given this item a rating of
91

Aging Room Small Batch M356 Rondo by Habana Cuba

Box of 20

Size

5 x 50

More Info

Origin

Dominican Republic

Wrapper

Habano

Shape

Regular
Also available in: 5 Cigars
Box of 20
5 x 50
$137.95
$153.72 - 10% off
FAQ icon
91
Cigar Insider has given this item a rating of
91

Aging Room Small Batch M356 Rondo by Habana Cuba

5 Cigars

Size

5 x 50

More Info

Origin

Dominican Republic

Wrapper

Habano

Shape

Regular
Also available in: Box of 20
5 Cigars
5 x 50
$37.95
$39.00 - 3% off
FAQ icon
92
Cigar Insider has given this item a rating of
92

Alec Bradley Family Blend D3

Box of 20

Size

4 1/2 x 58

More Info

Origin

Honduras

Wrapper

Natural

Shape

Regular
Box of 20
4 1/2 x 58
$100.95
$119.00 - 15% off
FAQ icon
91
Cigar Aficionado has given this item a rating of
91

Alec Bradley Family Blend M23

Box of 20

Size

7 x 50

More Info

Origin

Honduras

Wrapper

Natural

Shape

Regular
Box of 20
7 x 50
$123.95
$145.00 - 15% off
FAQ icon
94
Cigar Aficionado has given this item a rating of
94

Alec Bradley Family Blend T11

Box of 20

Size

6 1/8 x 52

More Info

Origin

Honduras

Wrapper

Natural

Shape

Torpedo
Also available in: 5 Cigars
Box of 20
6 1/8 x 52
$123.95
$145.00 - 15% off
FAQ icon