Reorder Now
1-888-412-4427

Contact Us
OPEN NOW UNTIL 9PM ET
1-888-412-4427

Call Now
Live Chat
  1. Home

Rated Cigars

Best Cigar Prices rated category features cigars that were reviewed and given top ratings (91+) by prestigious cigar publications such as Cigar Aficionado, Cigar Insider, Cigar Magazine and Smoke Magazine.

Our top rated cigars are known for their exceptional quality and value and are among some of the highest rated cigars on the market. We’re proud to offer premium cigars to our customers at a great price. These are some of the world’s finest cigars and they’re located all in one convenient place!

Sort
41 - 80 of 402
brands
strength
to
length
to
packaging
wrapper
rating
to
Reset
RATED
91 Arturo Fuente Hemingway Masterpiece Arturo Fuente Hemingway Masterpiece
from $13.20/stick
RATED
93 Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story
from $5.44/stick
(52)
RATED
92 Arturo Fuente Hemingway Signature Arturo Fuente Hemingway Signature
from $7.24/stick
(31)
RATED
94 Arturo Fuente Hemingway Work Of Art Arturo Fuente Hemingway Work Of Art
Item is Backordered
Notify Me  
from $7.92/stick
(8)
RATED
94 Arturo Fuente Hemingway Work Of Art Arturo Fuente Hemingway Work Of Art
Item is Backordered
Notify Me  
from $9.10/stick
RATED
91 Arturo Fuente Queen B Arturo Fuente Queen B
1-2 Week Backordered
Notify Me  
from $5.89/stick
(6)
RATED
92 Ashton Aged Maduro #60 Ashton Aged Maduro #60
from $11.16/stick
Free Shipping
valued at $7.99
RATED
91 Ashton Estate Sun Grown (Esg) 21 Year Salute Ashton Estate Sun Grown (esg) 21 Year Salute
from $16.44/stick
RATED
93 Ashton Estate Sun Grown (Esg) 22 Year Salute Ashton Estate Sun Grown (esg) 22 Year Salute
from $18.92/stick
Free Shipping
valued at $7.99
(5)
RATED
92 Ashton Estate Sun Grown (Esg) 24 Year Salute Ashton Estate Sun Grown (esg) 24 Year Salute
from $19.80/stick
Free Shipping
valued at $7.99
RATED
94 Ashton Heritage Puro Sol Belicoso #2 Ashton Heritage Puro Sol Belicoso #2
from $9.32/stick
RATED
94 Ashton Heritage Puro Sol Churchill Ashton Heritage Puro Sol Churchill
from $9.76/stick
Free Shipping
valued at $7.99
RATED
94 Ashton Heritage Puro Sol Corona Gorda Ashton Heritage Puro Sol Corona Gorda
from $9.40/stick
RATED
94 Ashton Heritage Puro Sol Robusto Ashton Heritage Puro Sol Robusto
from $9.24/stick
Free Shipping
valued at $7.99
RATED
94 Ashton Symmetry Belicoso Ashton Symmetry Belicoso
Item is Backordered
Notify Me  
from $12.20/stick
RATED
94 Ashton Symmetry Belicoso Ashton Symmetry Belicoso
from $11.56/stick
Free Shipping
valued at $7.99
RATED
93 Ashton Symmetry Prestige Ashton Symmetry Prestige
from $12.16/stick
Free Shipping
valued at $7.99
RATED
94 Ashton Symmetry Robusto Ashton Symmetry Robusto
from $11.40/stick
Free Shipping
valued at $7.99
RATED
93 Ashton Vsg Belicoso #1 Ashton Vsg Belicoso #1
from $10.67/stick
Free Shipping
valued at $7.99
(5)
RATED
91 Ashton Vsg Corona Gorda Ashton Vsg Corona Gorda
from $10.46/stick
RATED
92 Ashton Vsg Eclipse Ashton Vsg Eclipse
from $12.83/stick
(5)
RATED
92 Ashton Vsg Enchantment Ashton Vsg Enchantment
from $11.91/stick
Free Shipping
valued at $7.99
RATED
91 Ashton Vsg Illusion Ashton Vsg Illusion
from $10.25/stick
RATED
92 Ashton Vsg Robusto Ashton Vsg Robusto
from $10.58/stick
RATED
92 Ashton Vsg Sorcerer Ashton Vsg Sorcerer
from $11.17/stick
Free Shipping
valued at $7.99
(7)
RATED
94 Ashton Vsg Spellbound Ashton Vsg Spellbound
from $13.75/stick
Free Shipping
valued at $7.99
(7)
RATED
93 Ashton Vsg Torpedo Ashton Vsg Torpedo
from $12.33/stick
(11)
RATED
92 Ashton Vsg Tres Mystique Ashton Vsg Tres Mystique
from $9.25/stick
Free Shipping
valued at $7.99
RATED
92 Ashton Vsg Wizard Ashton Vsg Wizard
from $12.86/stick
Free Shipping
valued at $7.99
RATED
94 Asylum 44 X 4 Asylum 44 X 4
from $4.46/stick
Gift Card
valued at $10.00
RATED
91 AVO Domaine 20 Avo Domaine 20
from $9.90/stick
Free Bonus
valued at $49.95
RATED
91 AVO Maduro 30 Year No. 2 Avo Maduro 30 Year No. 2
from $9.45/stick
RATED
93 AVO Syncro Nicaragua Toro Avo Syncro Nicaragua Toro
from $9.81/stick
Free Bonus
valued at $49.95
RATED
91 Brick House Churchill Brick House Churchill
from $6.48/stick
Free Shipping & Bonus
valued at $38.99
RATED
93 Brick House Corona Larga Brick House Corona Larga
from $5.60/stick
Free Bonus
valued at $31.00
RATED
91 Brick House Mighty Mighty Brick House Mighty Mighty
from $6.68/stick
(6)
RATED
92 Brick House Robusto Brick House Robusto
from $5.76/stick
Free Bonus
valued at $31.00
(11)
RATED
91 Brick House Toro Brick House Toro
from $5.67/stick
Free Bonus
valued at $31.00
(5)
RATED
92 Cain F Series Habano 550 Cain F Series Habano 550
from $4.58/stick
(12)
RATED
92 Cain F Series Habano 550 Tubo Cain F Series Habano 550 Tubo
from $5.71/stick
Free Shipping
valued at $7.99

Need Help?

That’s what we’re here for.
MON-FRI 8AM-9PM, SAT-SUN 9AM-5PM ET

Call: 1-888-412-4427 Call: 1-888-412-4427, or Live Chat Now

Email Sign-Up

Get first crack at our greatest deals sent straight to your inbox.

View Catalog

Didn’t get our latest catalog? You poor thing. Check it out here, and sign up for a free subscription so you won’t miss the next one!

View Catalog

Shop

Learn More

Easy, Safe, & Secure

100% Satisfaction Guarantee
BBB A+ Rating
View Desktop Site
Copyright © 2019, Best Cigar Prices WARNING: Best Cigar Prices does not sell cigars or tobacco related products to anyone under the age of 21, nor do we sell cigarettes. You must be 21 to purchase tobacco products. Do not enter this website if you are not of the legal minimum age.