Greatest Of All Time
Your browser does not support JavaScript, or it is disabled. You will not be able to properly use this site until you enable JavaScript
x1
30-day or get $10
We'll beat any advertised price online or in-store by $10. If we don't carry the item or have it in stock, we'll send you a free $10 gift certificate just for telling us.
35-day returns
BCP has the most customer friendly return policy in the business. Return to us in qualifying condition within 35 days from delivery for a full refund.
Get it by Tomorrow
We ship fast. All in-stock items ordered by 2:00 PM ET are typically shipped the same business day. See more shipping options in checkout.
| Count | 5 Cigars |
| Diameter | 50 Ring |
| Length | 5 Inches |
| Origin | Dominican Republic |
| Packaging | Sealed Pack |
| Shape | Regular |
| Strength | Medium |
| Wrapper | Sumatra |
| Item # | 234592 |
The Secret of the Island Is Out.
A closely-guarded artisan tobacco blend paying homage to the brand’s roots, the super-premium Macanudo Rare Select has arrived at BCP.
Showcasing a flawless Ecuadoran Sumatra wrapper leaf over Nicaraguan binder and tercio-aged filler tobaccos from the top growing regions of the Dominican Republic and Nicaragua, as well as rare Cuban-seed tobacco leaves grown in the brand’s founding nation of Jamaica, the Macanudo Rare Select shines with warm and inviting flavor like none other. Boasting rich notes of oak, espresso, and almond with citrus undertones and hints of pepper, this unique, medium-full-bodied expression delivers silky taste that’s smooth to the last delicious puff.
Note: packaging style may vary as we transition to a new look for Rare Select blends
I love these cigars. Well made,easy draw,stays lite.
By Scott on May 6, 2020
This is a good 9 how cigar. Relaxing walk with a medium bodied cigar. Easy draw.
By David on Oct 20, 2022
I purchased a box of punch cigars with the bonus of a 5 pack of Mac,rare select for a dollar. What a steal a good medium bodied smoke. I smoke full bodied cigars, they were a nice change up. Thanks
By Raymond on Jan 24, 2020
Very nice finish and not a hard after taste
By John on Nov 15, 2022
Smooth taste burns great - I would buy again
By Michael on Nov 8, 2022
Nice
By William on Nov 10, 2020
My friends and I enjoyed these very much!
By Orlando on Dec 14, 2023
Enjoyed my day by starting with this fine cigar!
By Thomas on Apr 1, 2021
Great cigar good flavor good price
By Michael on Sep 22, 2022
Good cigar
By Robert on Jan 4, 2022
Good taste and burn
By randall on Nov 7, 2023
Mellow as you would expect a macanudo to be. Nice flavor with a medium body. I enjoyed them!
By corey on Nov 5, 2020
Macanudo was the first handmade cigar I tried.Enjoyed them,so smoked them for many years.These are,in my opinion more flavorful then most Macs I've smoke.Easy draw,some spice and nice burn,Will purchase again.Great value as are all 5 packs I've purchased from BCP.
By Tom on Sep 22, 2022
Nice full flavor with a dark, Spivey wrapper. These burn full & slow, very even all the way. These things are durable - great for outdoor activities, especially on the river fishing.
By Brent on Apr 7, 2022
Always great products and fast service.
By Geary on Oct 13, 2022
Great set of cigars, nice easy draw, with a mild smokie leather scent that is easy on your guest.
By Mostafa on Oct 13, 2020
Great golf course cigar. Burns about one hour, medium strength.
By Dell on Jun 8, 2021
Decent little cigars, for when you need a shorter smoke.
By Dale on Sep 20, 2022
These are very smooth and burn 🔥 evenly I recommend 👌
By Anthony on Sep 1, 2022
The Mac’s are a great smoke for an end of the day relaxer. I highly recommend it and the service from the Best Cigar Company was exceptional. They will continue to be my go to source for good reasonably priced cigars.
By Lee on Jun 25, 2021
Couldnt pass up this pack for the price
By Donald on Sep 6, 2022
This is a great stick for the price. It’s delicious and burns evenly ride to the very end.
By David on Jun 17, 2021
Great Cigar, good draw and taste.
By Varouj on Apr 9, 2024
A good anytime cigar , tight wrap.
By Vito on Sep 22, 2021
The Macanudo Rare Select Robusto lives up to the quality that Macanudo is known for. It's the type of cigar you want to have as you relax on the patio with an adult beverage.
By Lawerence on Sep 22, 2022
Got these Macs as a bonus to my order and wasn’t expecting a lot. I was very surprised at what a sublime smoke these cigars provided. Milder than my usual Padron 3000 naturals and provided a pleasant contrast. I would order these again. High quality and excellent construction. Love Bestcigarprices !!!!
By marc on Apr 28, 2020
The price could not have been beaten for this quality smoke!!
By Lawrence on Jun 16, 2022
perfect for a quick smoke
By Joe on Apr 27, 2021
This brand is always good, these were too. No burn or draw issues
By John on May 11, 2023
I was never a Macanudo cigar fan because I was only given "green" cigars and not appealing to me. The maduro rare select was a winner first taste. Just ordered some more
By Thomas on Sep 21, 2021
I like it
By Yosi on Dec 19, 2023
Great cigar as macanudo is always good price too
By Robert on Jun 8, 2023
These smoked hot because they were loosely rolled. The burn was uneven and the flavor wasn't what I was hoping for.
By james on Jul 18, 2024
Rich, Smooth and enjoyable cigar.
By Vincent on Feb 2, 2023
Really enjoyed smooth nice aroma fresh
By Paul on Jul 12, 2022
It's not often I find a cigar that I don't like but these are just plain awful.
By Matthew on Sep 1, 2020
Strong to medium smoke with a good even burn and paired with a nice peaty single malt these will make your evening complete.
By Henry on Jan 5, 2023
good quality and good price
By John on Apr 23, 2020
out of 18 cigars only one burned slightly off and not even that bad. I call that a home run, just placed order for 2nd box
By Tom on Jan 15, 2019
Good burn, great full taste, will purchase again
By George on Jan 15, 2019
Well done stick. Smooth from start to finish.
By Kevin on Mar 17, 2020
Excellent cigar, especially for the price. Top shelf in all regards.
By Brian on Jan 15, 2019
These cigars are Macanudo smooth. I appreciated the strength of these cigars as apposed to my regular bolder smoke. Will order again. Another bargain form bestcigarprices !!!!
By marc on Feb 25, 2021
I smoke the mac cafe in the mornings with my coffee. This stick is great anytime. Love the flavor and the burn is even. If you like Mac's this will not dissapoint.
By David on Mar 17, 2023
Great smoke, well made.
By Charles on Oct 11, 2023
medium-full bodied, delicious and creamy smooth
exceeds Macanudo high standards.
I lean toward a light wrapper which this stick has with its Equadorian/Sumatran leaf
recommend highly
By Leslie on May 16, 2019
Love Dominican cigars, was recommended to try the Macano Rare Select and it is a strong burn. Nice flavor, burned for longer than most robustos
By Frank on Jan 15, 2019
Rare selects were a delight. Smooth but flavorful!
By Rob on Nov 7, 2023
They reminded me of the lord Nelson crossed with a 1986 vintage rare
By Ralph on Sep 7, 2021
These cigars smoke very well. However they were not as mild as suggested
By John on Jun 25, 2020
NEW MACANUDO RARE SELECT HAS OVERTAKEN THE CRU ROYALE AS MY ALL TIME FAVORITE MACANUDO CIGAR. THIS IS A SPECIAL OCCASSION SMOKE FOR ME, BUT THOSE OCCASSIONS ARE VERY SPECIAL
By David on Jan 15, 2019
Received these, and of the 18, 10 were rolled extremely tight and wouldn't draw without minor surgery to the stick. 3 burnt like California in the fall, and the final 5 were fine. Not great, fine. For the price, these cigars are NOT worth the order.
By Matthew on Jun 16, 2020
| Count | 5 Cigars |
| Diameter | 50 Ring |
| Length | 5 Inches |
| Origin | Dominican Republic |
| Packaging | Sealed Pack |
| Shape | Regular |
| Strength | Medium |
| Wrapper | Sumatra |
| Item # | 234592 |
