Greatest Deals of All Time

GUEST
0 Point Available

Sign In

Shop by Brand

Dynamite Deals

Order Status

About Us 🐐

Help
FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $99
FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $99
Best Price Guarantee
BBB A+ Rating
American Owned
  1. Home >
  2. Sale

Introducing the Rare Select Family!

Injecting a new vibrancy into some of the world's most respected cigar lines, the Rare Select series is a collection of modern expressions from time-tested brands, blended to accommodate today's sophisticated palates.

FILTERS

CAO (4)
Macanudo (4)
Punch (4)
CAO Rare Select (4)
Macanudo Rare Select (4)
Punch Rare Select (4)
Dominican Republic (4)
Honduras (4)
Nicaragua (4)
Medium (8)
Medium-Full (4)
Connecticut Broadleaf (4)
Sumatra (4)
Sungrown (4)
Price

Price Per Stick

4" - 6" (5)
6" - 8" (5)
50 - 54 (11)
55 - 60 (1)
60 - 64 (1)
In Stock?
Cigar Only?
Clear All Filters
More Active Sales Smoke breaks up to 45% OFF! Flavored & Infused Stix from $14.99 BILLY'S DAILY DEAL - Punch Rare Select Robusto 5 Pack $24.99 + Free Shipping! Bundle Price Drop Big-Brand Grand Slam 250+ Packs from $5.99… 12 Romeo sticks under $4.20 ea. 10 FREE Gurkha cigars inside Claim 5 Drew Infused sticks FREE! 40% OFF Monte Starts NOW! Alec Bradley Flight Packs Sampler Savings: up to 60% OFF 100+ Best-Sellers up to 60% OFF… Howdy! Here’s 30% OFF Romeo 1875 $19.99 Cigar Packs La Gloria Days: $30 OFF Boxes… Trust me. Dad wants Oliva. Get Dad a Humi & nearly $30 in Freebies… Exhibition Bout: top brands from $19.99 25 Caldwell sticks under $6 ea. Billy’s Secret Stache 15 of Oliva’s Greatest Hits: $89.99
Sort
CAO Rare Select Toro
Cao Rare Select Toro
$96.99
$138.99
$173.45 MSRP
Free Shipping
Add to Cart

(12)
CAO Rare Select Robusto
Cao Rare Select Robusto
$91.99
$127.99
$159.98 MSRP
Free Shipping
Add to Cart

(10)
Punch Rare Select Toro
Punch Rare Select Toro
$124.99
$134.99
$169.12 MSRP
Free Shipping
Add to Cart

(15)
CAO Rare Select Short Robusto
Cao Rare Select Short Robusto
$84.99
$119.99
$150.88 MSRP
Free Shipping
Add to Cart

Punch Rare Select Suprema Churchill Extra
Punch Rare Select Suprema Churchill Extra
$139.99
$149.99
$169.50 MSRP
Free Shipping
Add to Cart

Punch Rare Select Churchill
Punch Rare Select Churchill
$134.99
$144.99
$164.50 MSRP
Free Shipping
Add to Cart

Macanudo Rare Select Suprema Churchill Extra
Macanudo Rare Select Suprema Churchill Extra
$124.99
$214.99
$268.88 MSRP
Free Shipping
Add to Cart

(9)
Macanudo Rare Select Robusto
Macanudo Rare Select Robusto
$125.99
$196.99
$246.71 MSRP
Free Shipping
Add to Cart

Macanudo Rare Select Toro
Macanudo Rare Select Toro
$133.99
$204.99
$255.82 MSRP
Free Shipping
Add to Cart

Punch Rare Select Robusto
Punch Rare Select Robusto
$114.99
$124.99
$139.50 MSRP
Free Shipping
Add to Cart

(51)
CAO Rare Select Gordo
Cao Rare Select Gordo

SOLD OUT
Notify Me  
$114.99
$129.99
$161.96 MSRP
Free Shipping

Macanudo Rare Select Churchill
Macanudo Rare Select Churchill
$139.99
$209.99
$262.15 MSRP
Free Shipping
Add to Cart

Need Help?

That’s what we’re here for.
MON-FRI 8AM-8PM, SAT-SUN 9AM-5PM ET
Call: 1-888-412-4427, or Live Chat Now

Email Sign-Up

Get first crack at our greatest deals sent straight to your inbox.

View Catalog

Didn’t get our latest catalog? You poor thing. Check it out here, and sign up for a free subscription so you won’t miss the next one!
View Catalog

Shop

Learn More

Easy, Safe, & Secure

100% Satisfaction Guarantee
BBB A+ Rating
American Owned

Follow Us

Copyright © 1997 - 2026, Best Cigar Prices WARNING: Best Cigar Prices does not sell cigars or tobacco related products to anyone under the age of 21, nor do we sell cigarettes. You must be 21 to purchase tobacco products. Do not enter this website if you are not of the legal minimum age. All items sold are for personal use and not for resale.
  • Your CA Privacy Rights
  • CO & VA Privacy Rights
  • Canadian Privacy Rights
  • Do Not Sell My Personal Information
  • Request My Personal Information
  • Privacy Policy
  • Rewards Policy
  • Cookie Preferences
  • Mobile Terms
  • Terms of Use

This website uses cookies. Learn more about cookies