FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $99
FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $99
Best Price Guarantee
BBB A+ Rating
American Owned
  1. Home >
  2. Rare Cigars

Rare Cigars

Rare Cigars at Best Cigar Prices

Browse through our selection of unique, premium, and rare cigars originating from countries like Nicaragua, Dominican Republic, and Honduras. Option include brands such as Alec Bradley, Arturo Fuente, AVO, Camacho Diploma, Gurkha, La Flor Dominicana, Padron, Tatuaje, and more. Find rare cigars in mellow-medium to full strengths with a range of lengths like 4-inches to 9-inches. Available in boxes, sampler packs, sticks, 2x deals, and bundles. Rare cigars in quality conditions at the lowest prices at Best Cigar Prices.

FILTERS

Padron (131)
Liga Privada (34)
God of Fire (32)
Punch (23)
La Flor Dominicana (18)
Ashton (14)
Opus X (13)
Arturo Fuente (7)
Macanudo (7)
Davidoff (5)
Caldwell (4)
Caldwell Lost & Found (4)
Oliva (3)
Drew Estate (2)
Dunbarton Tobacco and Trust (Saka) (2)
Espinosa (2)
GAR (2)
Joya de Nicaragua (2)
Partagas (2)
Tatuaje (2)
Aganorsa Leaf (1)
CAO (1)
Chogui (1)
Crowned Heads (1)
Don Pepin (1)
Foundation Cigars (1)
Fratello (1)
JFR (1)
La Aroma de Cuba (1)
La Palina (1)
Montecristo (1)
Rocky Patel (1)
Room 101 (1)
Southern Draw (1)
VegaFina (1)
Show More
Padron Anniversario Serie 1964 (43)
Padron Anniversario Serie 1926 (35)
Punch Rare Corojo (23)
Padron Family Reserve (13)
Ashton Virgin Sun Grown (9)
Macanudo Gold (7)
Padron Damaso (6)
Ashton Estate Sun Grown (4)
Sencillo Black (4)
Sencillo Platinum (4)
Anastasia by Caldwell (3)
Arturo Fuente Don Carlos (3)
Arturo Fuente Hemingway (3)
George Rico El Enemigo (2)
Joya de Nicaragua Numero Uno (2)
Padron Black (2)
Angelenos (1)
Ashton Heritage Puro Sol (1)
CAO Amazon (1)
Caldwell Long Live the Queen (1)
Davidoff Aniversario (1)
Davidoff Maduro (1)
Davidoff Signature Series (1)
Davidoff Winston Churchill (1)
Espada by Montecristo (1)
Four Kicks (1)
Herrera Esteli (1)
La Aroma de Cuba Noblesse (1)
La Flor Dominicana Double Ligero (1)
Muestra de Saka (1)
My Father (1)
Oliva Serie V (1)
Partagas Valle Verde (1)
Rocky Patel Aged Limited Rare Second Edition (1)
Sin Compromiso (1)
Southern Draw Rose of Sharon (1)
Tabernacle (1)
Undercrown (1)
Show More
Nicaragua (193)
Dominican Republic (99)
Honduras (28)
Various (2)
Denmark (1)
United States (1)
10 (74)
5 (45)
25 (42)
20 (33)
26 (26)
24 (22)
4 (15)
50 (13)
8 (10)
6 (9)
12 (9)
1 (6)
15 (5)
13 (4)
48 (4)
40 (2)
2 (1)
7 (1)
16 (1)
18 (1)
100 (1)
Show More
Mellow (8)
Mellow-Medium (10)
Medium (30)
Medium-Full (132)
Full (127)
Various (13)
Box (236)
Loose Pack (52)
2X Deal (16)
Cigars in Humidor (7)
Stick (6)
Sealed Pack (5)
Bundle (1)
Cigars with Cutter (1)
Regular (255)
Torpedo (23)
Perfecto (15)
Pyramid (7)
Pigtail (6)
Various (6)
Belicoso (5)
Chisel (2)
Diademas (2)
Figurado (2)
Show More
Maduro (70)
Natural (44)
Sungrown (44)
Sumatra (37)
Connecticut (28)
Habano (26)
Connecticut Broadleaf (15)
Oscuro (13)
Ecuadorian (11)
Cameroon (10)
Corojo (5)
Honduran (4)
Nicaraguan (4)
Various (4)
Mexican San Andres (3)
Dominican Republic (2)
Colorado (1)
Show More
Price

Price Per Stick

4" - 6" (64)
6" - 8" (58)
Under 4" (8)
Over 8" (3)
Not Rated (169)
91 to 95 (91)
86 to 90 (49)
96 to 100 (14)
81 to 85 (1)
Under 43 (30)
44 - 49 (51)
50 - 54 (167)
55 - 60 (53)
60 - 64 (33)
65 - 70 (1)
70 & Over (1)
In Stock?
Cigar Only?
Clear All Filters
Sort
Featured
Featured
God of Fire Serie B Double Robusto
God Of Fire Serie B Double Robusto

Rare & Out of Stock
Notify Me  
$225.00
Featured
Featured
Featured
Featured
RATED
94 Ashton Vsg Illusion
Ashton Vsg Illusion
$55.99
EARN 112 REWARD POINTS
(5)
Featured
RATED
90 Punch Rare Corojo Pita
Punch Rare Corojo Pita

Item is Backordered
Notify Me  
$37.99
RATED
87 Macanudo Gold Label Shakespeare
Macanudo Gold Label Shakespeare
$243.99
Free Bonus
valued at $40.95
RATED
90 Ashton Vsg Pegasus
Ashton Vsg Pegasus
$57.99
EARN 116 REWARD POINTS
RATED
90 Liga Privada Unico Serie Lp40
Liga Privada Unico Serie Lp40
$280.97
Gift Card
valued at $15.00
RATED
94 Ashton Vsg Sorcerer
Ashton Vsg Sorcerer
$59.99
EARN 120 REWARD POINTS
(9)
Foundation Tabernacle Knight Commander
Foundation Tabernacle Knight Commander
$431.99
EARN 864 REWARD POINTS
Padron Black PB97 Torpedo Maduro
Padron Black Pb97 Torpedo Maduro

Rare & Out of Stock
Notify Me  
$400.97
RATED
91 Padron Damaso No. 34
Padron Damaso No. 34

Rare & Out of Stock
Notify Me  
$331.97
RATED
89 Padron Delicias Natural
Padron Delicias Natural

Rare & Out of Stock
Notify Me  
$213.97
Padron Delicias Maduro
Padron Delicias Maduro

Rare & Out of Stock
Notify Me  
$213.97
RATED
89 Padron Damaso No. 17
Padron Damaso No. 17
$391.97
EARN 784 REWARD POINTS
Padron Damaso No. 15
Padron Damaso No. 15
$341.97
EARN 684 REWARD POINTS
Caldwell Lost & Found Cream Machine Toro
Caldwell Lost & Found Cream Machine Toro
$152.99
EARN 306 REWARD POINTS
George Rico El Enemigo El Insulto
George Rico El Enemigo El Insulto
$311.97
EARN 624 REWARD POINTS
Don Carlos Edicion de Aniversario Double Robusto
Don Carlos Edicion De Aniversario Double Robusto
$395.00
Free ONE DAY Delivery & Gift Card
valued at $36.99
Liga Privada 10 Year Aniversario Robusto
Liga Privada 10 Year Aniversario Robusto
$184.97
EARN 370 REWARD POINTS
Sencillo Black Piramid Largo 54
Sencillo Black Piramid Largo 54

Rare & Out of Stock
Notify Me  
$268.75
Free ONE DAY Delivery & Gift Card
valued at $36.99
La Palina 125 Anniversary Anos
La Palina 125 Anniversary Anos
$233.99
EARN 468 REWARD POINTS
Anastasia Kartel by Caldwell
Anastasia Kartel By Caldwell
$528.99
Free ONE DAY Delivery
valued at $68.49
God of Fire Serie Aniversario 54
God Of Fire Serie Aniversario 54
$325.00
Free ONE DAY Delivery & Gift Card
valued at $36.99
RATED
93 Padron Anniversario Serie 1926 #2 Maduro
Padron Anniversario Serie 1926 #2 Maduro
$128.97
EARN 258 REWARD POINTS
(17)
God of Fire Serie B Robusto
God Of Fire Serie B Robusto
$270.00
Free ONE DAY Delivery & Gift Card
valued at $36.99
RATED
90 Punch Rare Corojo En Crystale
Punch Rare Corojo En Crystale
$181.99
Gift Card
valued at $74.99
Padron Anniversario Serie 1964 Hermoso Maduro
Padron Anniversario Serie 1964 Hermoso Maduro
$79.97
EARN 160 REWARD POINTS
(9)

More About Rare Cigars

Browse through our selection of unique, premium, and rare cigars originating from countries like Nicaragua, Dominican Republic, and Honduras. Option include brands such as Alec Bradley, Arturo Fuente, AVO, Camacho Diploma, Gurkha, La Flor Dominicana, Padron, Tatuaje, and more. Find rare cigars in mellow-medium to full strengths with a range of lengths like 4-inches to 9-inches. Available in boxes, sampler packs, sticks, 2x deals, and bundles. Rare cigars in quality conditions at the lowest prices at Best Cigar Prices.

Need Help?

That’s what we’re here for.
MON-FRI 8AM-8PM, SAT-SUN 9AM-5PM ET
Call: 1-888-412-4427, or Live Chat Now

Email Sign-Up

Get first crack at our greatest deals sent straight to your inbox.

View Catalog

Didn’t get our latest catalog? You poor thing. Check it out here, and sign up for a free subscription so you won’t miss the next one!
View Catalog

Shop

Learn More

Easy, Safe, & Secure

100% Satisfaction Guarantee
BBB A+ Rating
American Owned

Follow Us

Copyright © 1997 - 2025, Best Cigar Prices WARNING: Best Cigar Prices does not sell cigars or tobacco related products to anyone under the age of 21, nor do we sell cigarettes. You must be 21 to purchase tobacco products. Do not enter this website if you are not of the legal minimum age. All items sold are for personal use and not for resale.
  • Your CA Privacy Rights
  • CO & VA Privacy Rights
  • Canadian Privacy Rights
  • Do Not Sell My Personal Information
  • Request My Personal Information
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Preferences
  • Mobile Terms
  • Terms of Use

This website uses cookies. Learn more about cookies